home toffee left

Simmering Sugar’s toffee is, quite simply, the best toffee around, all year round. We use fresh, premium ingredients with no preservatives or coloring so that the mouthwatering flavor is detected throughout every scrumptious bite.

Me oh my! What flavor to try?? For the indecisive customer we suggest starting out with the Simmering Sugar Sampler that comes with a taste of four different decadent flavors so you’ll be able to find your favorite toffee treat!

We make all orders within 24 hours so you can rest assured that your toffee will be fresh, crunchy, and delectable upon arrival and for many days after!

home toffee right

Simmering Sugar is a gourmet, made- to-order toffee company established and run by toffee enthusiasts Sharon and Katie Kelley (also a mother/ daughter team!)

Disclaimer: Eat with caution! Simmering Sugar is considered addictive!